‘Jinnah’s Orphans’

A Book Proposal by Tarek Fatah

1947 population transfer

How the Partition of India and the creation of Pakistan gave birth to the scourge of Islamic terrorism and threatens world peace, and how Partition continues to bleed the Subcontinent every day.


Mass migration during independence of India 13Sixty five years after the partition of India and the birth of Pakistan that saw a bloodbath on the plains of Punjab and the Ganges delta in Bengal, the tragedy continues to produce new victims. This time its not just in Punjab and Bengal, but right across the world. These victims and the events that led to them are the ‘Orphans of Jinnah’ and his two-nation theory that resulted into the amputation of India’s limbs.

The ramifications of M. A. Jinnah’s misadventure are being felt across the globe as every day, acts of terror are committed that can be traced back to the Land of the Pure—Pakistan.

War on Terror

12 years after the United States and its Western allies declared their ‘war on terror,’ there is little sign of America succeeding in its objectives or even understanding the enemy it is supposed to defeat.

The effective strategy to fight malaria is to drain the swamps, not kill individual mosquitos. Unfortunately in their effort to fight the malaria of terrorism, India, NATO and the U.S. have killed thousands, including Osama Bin Laden, but have done little to drain the swamp where these jihadis breed.

From Khalid Sheikh Mohammad’s 9/11 plans to the recent recruitment of jihadis in Burma, from the Toronto 18 to the London 7/7 bombings, fingerprints of Pakistan-based jihadi groups and ideologies are ubiquitous. America keeps pumping billions into the coffers of the Pakistan Army that shelters Mulla Omar and nurtures through its political establishment tens of thousands of young Muslim men willing to die to destroy the West.

The question is this: Why is it primarily Pakistan among the Islamic countries of the world that provides fertile soil for the men and ideology of Islamist terrorism? Why not Turkey, Indonesia, the Palestinian Authority or even Iran?

To answer this question, one has to go back to the genesis of Pakistan, its amputation from India by Britain, and its development as frontline state against communism by the U.S.

Conventional wisdom and traditional scholarship dictates, Pakistan came about as a result of Muslim grievances and fear of a Hindu-majority rule in post British India. Mohammad Ali Jinnah and the All India Muslim League are given credit for tapping into this sense of victimhood that still drives much of Islamist anger around the world.

However, there is more to it than meets the eye.

End of World War Two

On May 5, 1945, the very day Germany surrendered, Prime Minister Churchill ordered an appraisal of “the long-term policy required to safeguard the strategic interests of the British Empire in India and the Indian Ocean.”

Two weeks later Churchill received the top-secret report that, among other proposals, mentioned the necessity of British presence in Northwest India (today’s Pakistan) “from which British air power could threaten Soviet military installations.”

When this was brought to the attention of Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, India’s Prime Minister and the Congress, they made it clear they would not accept British bases on Indian soil. On the other hand, Muslim League leader Jinnah was amenable to such an idea.

But two months later, Churchill was shockingly defeated by the Labour Party in the election, leaving the task of creating Pakistan for the sake of Western military strategic needs to the socialists.

By June 1947, the decision to amputate India was announced in London. It was left to British foreign secretary Ernst Bevin to explain to his party activists why London would seek to destroy what it had built over 100 years as the “Jewel of the British Crown.” Defending the decision that would devastate the lives of millions for decades, Bevin told delegates at a Labour Party Conference that the division of India was necessary because it “would help to consolidate Britain in the Middle East.”

It’s no coincidence that within a few years, the U.S. would establish an air base in Pakistan to launch its high altitude U2 spy aircraft until one day in 1960 when a U2 was shot down over Russia and Gary Powers was captured.

Thus came the great divide on August 14-15, 1947. After partition, the UK handed over the baton to the US, who invested heavily into Pakistan becoming a frontline anti-communist military state.

Today, the USSR is dead, but Pakistan is alive and Jinnah’s orphans have become India and America’s demon; an evil genie that successive U.S. administrations cannot put back into the bottle and no amount of Indian diplomacy can contain.

The great MigrationJinnah’s Orphans

This book will dwell in detail how Pakistan was created by a false ideology that had no historical or rational basis and why the supposed Land of the Pure has become the master of the game of double-speak; taking Western aid to supposedly fight the war on terrorism, yet providing shelter and funding to the same terrorists it purports to fight.

The book will trace the roots of this behaviour to the tragic division of India and the monster of Islamism that morphed out of the Cold War and now haunts and hunts its own maker.

Chapter Outline

Chapter 1: The Bihari Camps of Bangladesh. The over one million stateless residents of Dhaka’s UN Refugee Camps whose grandparents were convinced by MA Jinnah to abandon their homes in Bihar, India and take refuge in what was then East Pakistan. Their parents sided with the Pakistan Army’s Genocide in East Pakistan in 1971 and after the creation of Bangladesh, they have lived as stateless refugees with neither India, Pakistan or Bangladesh accepting them as citizens. They are the truest inheritors of the title, Jinnah Orphans.

Chapter 2: Bankrupt Britain delivers a handicapped baby-state
The birth of Pakistan and the Partition of India in the wake of the Soviet expansion southwards after the end of World War II

Chapter 3: Jinnah’s first military adventure: Kashmir 1947
The invasion of the State of Jammu & Kashmir by Pashtun tribesman commanded by regular Pakistan Army officers. A discussion about the developments that even today cause the region to simmer and how Pakistan’s Military-Civil Establishment uses the dispute to fan the Indian bogey and maintain its stranglehold on the country.

Chapter 4: Jinnah hobnobs with the Nizam: Hyderabad Police Action 1948
With the Nizam of Hyderabad bankrolling Pakistan and refusing to join the Indian Union, India invades the princely state resulting in reprisal killings on a large scale between Hindus and Muslims

Chapter 5: Jinnah orders the invasion of the State of Kalat: Balochistan 1948
The current turmoil in Balochistan can be traced back to the invasion of the State of Kalat, an independent country, by the Pakistan Army in March 1948. That action in the name of Islam and Pakistan has led to four uprisings by the Baloch and is the cause of the current guerrilla war seeking independence.

Chapter 6: America adopts Pakistan as a ‘front-line’ state
After Britain faces bankruptcy, it hands over the West’s ‘East of Suez’ strategic assets to the USA with Pakistan as a front-line base to ward of communist expansion southward after China too turns red.

Chapter 7: Indo-Pakistan Wars and US neutrality
In 1965 India and Pakistan go to war, but the USA reneges on its treaties with Pakistan, refusing to come to its side, forcing Pakistan to jump into the lap of communist China and start building the so-called Islamic Bomb.

Chapter 8: The Genocide in Bangladesh in 1971
The 1970 elections in Pakistan lead to victory by the East Pakistan-based Awami League of Shaikh Mujib-ur-Rahman. The Pakistan Army and West Pakistan politicians refuse to handover power, resulting in the 1971 genocide of Bengali nationalists and the war between India and Pakistan in December 1971 with the birth of Bangladesh

Chapter 9: Khalistan – Pakistan’s response to Bangladesh
After its humiliating defeat in 1971, the Pakistan Establishment hits back at India by encouraging the separatist Khalistan Sikh movement. This chapter will outline the tragedy that befell India’s Punjab leading up to the Amritsar military action, the assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, the 1984 riots and the crackdown that followed.

Chapter 10: Red Army in Afghanistan vs. US in Pakistan
In the late 1970s, three regime changes in the region lay the foundation of today’s world. In Pakistan, a pro-American Islamist zealot close to the Saudis overthrows Prime Minister ZA Bhutto while in Iran the Shah is toppled by a revolution later stolen by the anti-American Shia Ayatollahs. Next-door in Kabul the government is toppled by pro-Soviet communists of Nur Tarraki, and the rest is history.

Chapter 11: Pakistan goes nuclear: The Islamic Bomb
A Pakistani metallurgical engineer working in The Netherlands steals blueprints of a nuclear facility and not only helps Islamabad build is nuclear Islamic bomb, but sets up an international network of nuclear merchants who sell the technology and parts to Iran, North Korea and Libya.

Chapter 12: 9/11 and the Made-in-Pakistan threat
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and Osama Bin Laden use Pakistan as their base to plan and execute the 9/11 plot with the logistical and ideological backing of segments of the Pakistan Army and its feared intelligence service, the ISI. That threat continues to this day as Pakistan backs the Taliban who fight the Americans both in Afghanistan and inside the USA.

Chapter 13: The feared ISI and its international tentacles
A study into the background and structure of the ISI and its links that stretch from Thailand’s Islamic insurgency to the Islamist groups those operate inside the USA.

Chapter 14: Draining the swamps
In the last chapter, the author will prescribe a strategy to neuter the jihadi monster. The chapter will identify areas the West has failed to address for fear of ‘offending’ its own Muslim populations and its relationship with the Saudis and Gulf Arab states.

23 comments for “‘Jinnah’s Orphans’

  1. F. Aziz
    December 25, 2013 at 7:25 AM

    Looking forward to this book even more than previous ones, as the stranded bihari’s issue is one that seemed to have drifted off in the mists of time. Thank you for the effort to uncover these oft-forgotten justices Tarek. God bless.

    • Waseem Haider
      February 14, 2014 at 1:58 PM

      Very right who is responsible for Bihari’s miseries and massacre, this also needs to be known to people

  2. Rohit Sharma
    December 26, 2013 at 4:26 PM

    Thanks Mr. Fateh, eagerly waiting for this book. Like to have your signed copy.

  3. Munish
    December 26, 2013 at 10:51 PM

    Looking forward for this book sir… Thank you for showing us true and undistorted history

  4. Waseem Haider
    January 5, 2014 at 9:07 PM

    Hope to see a behind the curtains story with on the screen faces. The chapters look full of inside information without prejudice and with an experts analysis, (let me use the word dissection of history and or dissection of characters of the play) an expert, who watches the game while sitting in experts cabin and tells the moves of every player, tells what would happen next and what are the required moves for altogether a different destination, because the expert knows and has research and knowledge of every player. Tarek sahib there were more changes on the globe, not only change of faces in Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan but also in some other countries, which may have direct or indirect relation to what evolved afterwards

  5. The Soldier
    January 23, 2014 at 2:46 PM

    This guy Tarek Fatah is a traitor and a bloody scoundrel! Shame on you..you bastard!

    • S Krishnan
      January 23, 2018 at 9:06 AM

      Truth is always bitter. Mirchi lagi Kay? Jinnah has sown the seed of poison and see his country. Thou shall you sow, so shall you reap.

  6. Jovi
    March 11, 2014 at 7:37 AM

    I really want to go through this book. I love the author and his brave confessions denouncing two nation theory and Jinnah

  7. Regular Reader
    March 18, 2014 at 6:02 AM

    Mr. Fatah; I am regular reader of your columns. I appreciate your honesty, courage and the uncommon common sense. I have read a whole lot of books (including your “Chasing a Mirage”) on the period of subcontinental independence and surprisingly come to the similar conclusion as yourself. I just wanted to point out one or two things (which you may already be aware of);

    1. Looks like the concept of jihad has been used a lot of times in history in wars of moslems against non-moslems even during invasions of India and uprisings against the British in the subcontinent (eg. 1857).

    2. Genocide, mass destruction, slavery, loot and plunder was always carried out in the name of Islam.

    3. Dara Shikoh was expected to succeed Shah Jahan. Aurangzeb succeeded on the shoulders of extremist ulema.

    4. Upon independence Gandhi, as leader of the congress, did not take on any position of political office. India requested Mountbatten to continue as Governor General during transition. Jinnah on the sought the position of Governor General of Pakistan. Obviously, he was in it all along for power.

    I feel these points have a bearing on some of your chapters.

    Thanks for your work and looking forward to more of your books.

  8. irfan
    March 22, 2014 at 5:42 AM

    looking forward to read your book.
    i love the personality of jinnah and would like to hear ur point.
    know that u r not his fan but hope you will write atleast one chapter on jinnah integrity, honesty and influential role.
    in short, there must be something good in this man.

  9. Mesbah Uddin
    May 8, 2014 at 9:28 AM

    Tarek Fatah is an excellent writer. Nevertheless, When a doctor’s diagnosis happens after the death of a patient, is it of any use to the patient’s parents and children?.

    • Aseem
      June 29, 2014 at 8:23 AM

      @Mesbahuddin: Those who do not learn from the history are cursed to repeat it. If the doctors abandon the actual reason for death, they will never be able to treat the similar patients.
      A piece of knowledge is always welcome.

    • Paul
      September 25, 2014 at 3:14 AM

      If the history of your past has been a lie, what can you say about your present or much less about your future? Lie to others all you want, but at least have the courage to tell yourself the truth.

  10. Aseem
    June 29, 2014 at 8:40 AM

    This will indeed be an interesting read. I am more keen to read the last chapter where the author is going to suggest a way forward.
    Any idea when the book will hit the stands? I would love to take pride in being one of the first readers of the book.

  11. Tony Valachi
    September 25, 2014 at 4:40 AM

    Sir, has this book been published? If yes, could you please tell me where to find it in India?

  12. Jez
    September 26, 2014 at 9:38 PM

    I am eagerly awaiting for your forthcoming book Mr. Fatah. I am so proud of you and your courage and truthfulness. Please keep it up.

  13. Rohit
    October 18, 2014 at 10:26 AM

    How soon can we read this book.??

  14. Divya Narayan
    December 31, 2014 at 12:44 AM

    Keen to read this book, when will the book be published?…

  15. Aditya
    January 2, 2015 at 7:04 PM

    Eagerly awaiting your book Mr. Fatah!

  16. Rakesh Sharma
    February 17, 2015 at 3:29 PM

    Dear Mr Fatah,

    Can you kindly give me an inclination as to when your book Jinnahs Orphans will come out? Thank you.


  17. TB
    March 23, 2015 at 4:56 AM

    Any idea when this book will be released?

  18. Puneet
    August 16, 2016 at 1:38 AM

    Eagerly waiting for this book. can you release it in hindi simultaneously so that hindi speaking people can also understand in depth

  19. Dr. Vivek Sahajpal
    April 4, 2017 at 2:46 AM

    Sir, I am waiting very eagerly for this book ever since I heard of its proposal. Many thanks for your earlier eye opening works that brought forth a true and undistorted account of events that have led to the genesis of the monsters & horrors of today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *