125 comments for “What Islamic Invaders really did to India – Muslim Historian Rizwan Saleem sets the record straight in The Hindustan Times

  1. Asif
    January 24, 2017 at 2:22 AM

    Dear Tarek,

    Thank you. “Wounded Civilization”, is our poor lovely India. So embarrassing to witness, to see the collective amnesia that afflicts its converted peoples of Hindustan. i.e. the so called Araby-sniffing muslims. We won’t acknowledge our ancestral roots and origins, as if accepting Islam had meant forsaking the past, forsaking our once rich and glorious heritage, our culture, our roots. Thick curtains have descended over our collective eyes that is preventing us the knowledge itself.

    Come come boys sing: sing the following pathetic song of salvery in unison,

    Jagg raha hai Pakistan/ upknee quiwath upknee jann/ Jagg raha hai Pakistan.
    Hum hain Tipu ki tulvar/Hum hain Tarek ka bazoo/Upknee quowath upknee jann/
    Jagg raha hai Pakistan, ( How bloody ridiculous?) Wake me up before you go girl?

    Islami Jahiliya, i’m being redundant here, is complete. Unless and until muslims device a new way of addressing Islam away from the temporal realm and relegating it to the spiritual realm, only then, we have a beginning of an end. The Dark Ages, Islam is trapped in the dark ages and any war of supremacy? Forgetaboutit. Spare parts of the lethal weapons of the 21st century that you may possess by purchasing from the west,,,well, that won’t enable your pipe dreams to become reality anytime soon. Just find peace in your opium fields and mud-brick homes of Hindu Kush mountain range of Afghanistan, where you may find easy to squat at virtually anywhere of your choosing to take a dump under the protection of the ever watchful eyes of the hovering drones laced with laser guided precision “hell-fire” missiles that will find you at the slightest of provocations.

    In one of his peculiar moods, as the good poet had once said:

    Ya rubb dilay muslim ko woe zinda tamanna day/jo rooh ko lullkaray,,,,bla bla bla

    Thanks for posting such a sober peace. God bless.



    • Jaswinder
      January 24, 2017 at 7:28 AM

      A sensible humon being

    • January 25, 2017 at 9:22 PM

      Dear Asif,
      Do you want to be an Apeman again, i.e. your ancestors ? Hah…..!!

      • Asif
        January 31, 2017 at 2:38 AM

        Feorz Kazi

        Mr. Kazi,

        Is it yet another attempt at being profound? An peman? Moi? Why, no. Oh joy, that is why we spend a lifetime reading, learning, and educating, indeed a painful undertaking that, a solitary struggle to overcome the accusation of the precise appellation that you seem to have so readily identified, of the longing of it in me. If anything, by the magnificence of our once manifest grandeur of the Hindu Civilization, its art, literature, the intricate philosophy, the glorious mythology rivaling nay even surpassing that of the Greeks, of our ancestors that we seems to have descended down to being quite apelike modern day muslims, world-wide aka the Jahiliya in our grotesque obsequies blood-thirsty ways, ass-snuffing of our even more ignorant, lowdown, simply un-educable, and utterly thick Araby overlords. Come, come Mr. Kazi wak-e wake-e, it takes a bigger and better man to acknowledge our own short comings: Learning begins: fifty percent of it is to acknowledge that we are trapped in the Dark Ages and the remaining fifty percent is to engage in the remedy: When the going gets tough the tough get cracking, so let’s roll up our sleeves…

        Muslims, should examine more closely one of the dogmas of their faith, namely presumptive “completeness” of Islam, as it is the most commonly held refrain that Islam offers a not, but the complete way of life; every thing has been addressed, no venue is left unsettled for the vagaries of life to encroach upon unfettered for conducting life. I have spent a lifetime studying and dwelling upon the Islamic world’s besetting sin: We have not come up from Hinduism but we most certainly have descended down to barbarism of Hivangi-Vehshiath, just look around, for examples, pray take your pick from the Islamic crescent from Morocco to the Philippines.

        So long is Islam under the delusion of the heady notion of perfection to think that Islam offers the complete zabita-i-Hiath (the Comprehensive way for life) we are destined to remain forever consigned to remaining in the wilderness, lost. I include myself with Tarek who are committed to sounding the clarion call for muslims world-wide to accept the western notion/invention of the secularism for the temporal world, that is to say man made laws hammered-out in the Assembly Halls of men and Houses of Parliaments after a robust, and open, very public discussions and debates to conduct our worldly affairs. Laws that are man-made may not be perfect and subject to tweaking, amendments if not rightout cancellations over time but over the long run we may get there by sheer tenacity and perseverance. Beside our earth is no Paradise, no perfection, we may do with slightly less than optimum for the sake of comity therefore suits us just fine as far as man made laws go, as in work in progress (WIP) just like anyone of us, mere mortals.

        No, Mr. Kazi, my Hindu ancestors were not “Apemen”, nor those who converted to Islam, but I certainly think modern day muslims are running the risk of being considered “apemen” if they continue to insist upon the “Sharia Supremacy” , for they are crude, primitive, Jahill, obnoxious, ridiculous and simply insupportable, either now or historically speaking anytime ever before.

        I acknowledge growth, learning, and education is quite painful, just look at the scene at any primary school class rooms: ’tis a hard business, a slog, slow grind over decades nay a lifetime is spent reading wide and in depth before the fog of miasma begins to clear any, and we begin to start identifying the shortcomings of our own. The above posted heart wrenching essay of Hindustan Times by Mr. Rizwan Salim elicited a heartfelt response from me in an impulse that I quite can’t explain, yes I’m sorry to my Hindu brethren for the sins of my forefathers who tolerated the pillaging of my beloved Hindustan. And I don’t apologize to anyone for having a deep and profound appreciation for the much superior civilization of our Hindu ancestry. And I sing Bharat Mata Ki Jai! Moreover a resounding Jai Hind! And, may the good Lord hastens the demise of the misbegotten state of Pakistan: Death to Pakistan (the Criminal State)! There, I said it. God bless.



        • Alm Chapel
          March 24, 2017 at 12:09 PM

          May I share ur post? Its awesome and more educated muslims should stand up and say they r proud of their ancesters instead of pandering to looters of our country. Salute to u.

          • Tarek Fatah
            March 24, 2017 at 1:18 PM

            Why not?

          • April 26, 2017 at 3:29 AM

            Unbelievable that people like Tarek and Asif are also there
            Hats off to you sir
            Pay such sense preavails hence the peace.

        • Ravi Padukone
          March 24, 2017 at 1:19 PM

          Remember, the Vedic culture professes secular spirit in both temporal and spiritual alike. Secularism is not an invention of modern day.

        • Rateesh
          March 24, 2017 at 10:01 PM

          Excellent !!

        • Kedilaya
          March 24, 2017 at 11:49 PM

          Asif bai..you said it ..world will be much more peaceful and livable if people of your calber increase ..thank u

        • Rajeev Gogte
          March 25, 2017 at 1:47 AM

          Dear Mr. Asif,
          Just one question comes to my mind after reading your most candid thoughts: are you really a Muslim? Or using a pseudonym to protect your identity and voice your thoughts?

        • Varun
          April 25, 2017 at 12:07 AM

          Asif you should be on twitter. What’s your handle

        • Anjan
          April 25, 2017 at 2:15 AM

          Dear Asif thanks for your self realizetion. Because of you guys we still dreaming the secular. India ??. We want peace with every faith, we respect too. We do believe everybody has right to do what he believed. But I don’t like the extravagant, our holly varot /?? it’s been civilized longer time ago, when there wasn’t university in Europe’s, but we had naloda university, which is demolished by Arabic in inveder, we are proud to having APJ Abul kalam, kazi najrul Islam, Mr tareq fatha sir, mufassil Islam and there is lots of unknown person those are Intalactual open minded person.. I have deep respect to them. I hope how the way you thought, everyone has to think ? like you and respect our ancient culture………….. Anjan from Bangladesh

        • ROS
          April 25, 2017 at 2:40 AM

          I really really appreciate ur response n have been waiting for atleast one Muslim intellect to give such a response . Any religion which doesn’t introspect , reinvents changes h
          It’s rules as per time is bound to create trouble for itself n rest of the society . Even Hinduism has kept reinventing itself only during the period of foreign invaders it became rigid , tyrannical n there only the rot of caste system , dowry etc set in . Thank fully modern India has given it a breath of fresh air . Hope people like u fight for that fresh air in ur religion .

        • Sharma
          April 25, 2017 at 3:23 AM

          Regards Asif bhai….Ur acknowledgement of ur ancestors being Hindus nd ur appreciation for Hindu Vedic Civilisation makes us happy…U can be considered one among d few muslims who can be called HEIRS of Hindu heritage shared with us.

        • john slawinski
          May 23, 2017 at 9:55 AM

          A very just view. I will add more. Allah THEIR god, is masculine. The Al is the equivalent of “the”. Lah can be found in a multitude of ways. The Egyptian moon god was name “Lah”. An Egyptian queen was also named “Lah” So Lah can be and has been feminine and masculine. This should tell you the Islamic god is indeed false. I will say this that man gave the gods personalities and a multitude of qualities and attributued demands or as people tend to say “the will of god”. Allah is nothing but a reflection of the minds of the Arab slave masters. The majority of muslim’s fear their god, alway’s seeking their gods mercy. That is exactly how a slave would respond to their master. Who has the power of life and death in all matters. There is no love from their god. Only if their actions “please” their god. In ending, allah is fake, a fabrication from a people whose desire was to have complete power over the lives of the many. That mohackmud was only a prophet of the man in the moon. That his original da’wa was rejected and he could not handle the feeling of this, then expressed these feelings through rage and made war on those who rejected him. Many Arab’s are ethno-centric and they project this into their religion (religio-centrism). When you feel this mighty any rejection would be catastrophic and the response deadly.

      • Sam
        April 24, 2017 at 11:05 PM

        Asif has evolved but you have slid back. Now throw the stick and climb down the tree, will ya!

        • Dibakar Bhattacharjee
          April 26, 2017 at 11:05 PM

          Yeah. That’s what we want to tell. Chuck away the muck from Arab and come back to your origin. The greatest civilization in the world.

    • Pankaj
      January 27, 2017 at 12:42 AM

      Islam has a date of its beginning n it’s destruction is coming soon..

      • Tarek Fatah
        January 28, 2017 at 2:37 AM

        Islam as a religion will live as long as Christianity, Sikhism and Sanatan Dharam lives. The issue is not Islam, but its use as a political tool of pression and war.

        • February 6, 2017 at 2:30 PM

          Sir lord krishna has said in geeta one which is born has to perish a day. Islam will also perish and has to perish because god of quran and laws of muhammad are against nature and humanity.

          I suggest u to plz read vedic hindu culture and meet arya mahendra pal ex maulvi who accepted arya samaj in 1965 and has brought many muslims brothers and sisters back to their roots. Arya mahendra pal and your collaboration will give new dimensions.

          • Raj
            March 13, 2017 at 2:42 AM

            Stop misquoting Lord Krishna! If you are Hindu, then sadly ignorant. ‘god of the Quran’ is no different than any other form of the Divine. Fundamental point of Sanatan Dharma.
            One God (is existence) but many forms.
            The fact that the teachings of the Prophet are twisted by the current ‘followers’ of Islam is no reflection on the Prophet.

            Krishna said to try and reach a peaceful consensus.. but with Islamists their position is evil. They have no goal but the destroy Hinduism and India. It is Hndu Dharma to fight against and evil which has no redeeming goodness.

          • Sheikh imran zafar
            March 26, 2017 at 10:13 AM

            How is laws of Mohammed and Quran against nature and humanity? Do you know what Islam is ? Or just love to hate it….Does people represent religion or vice versa? In that way in our country millions of Hindus are doing criminal activities are going jail and most of them are roaming freely…So we must conclude that Hinduism teaches criminal activities? Krishna said what was born will perish? Then according to your logic Hindu religion will perish too…Christianity will persih too….I dont know how yoy people find time to criticize other religion? Why compare? If you are Hindu,be a proud Hindu….Does Gita or Quran teaches to criticize???? No holy books does say it….but sorry to say,you are not so educated….Who is Tarek? A writer,an educated fellow…Does it mean that whatever he will write or share will be perfect….perspectives may differ….Dnt fill your heart with hatred….love all….if u can!

        • Ravindra Khatri
          March 24, 2017 at 12:08 PM

          Any human being ,to which ever religion he belongs can make an effort individually to cleanse the collective wrong done .The CONSPIRATORS.

          • Vivek
            April 25, 2017 at 1:26 AM

            Well Quran do teach to criticize , it criticize every1 who don’t follow Islam.

        • Puneet
          March 24, 2017 at 1:03 PM

          If a guy like Asif exists in India, I exult in joy as I now believe, our country can be redeemed. Today we need Indians more than anything. And I believe, even a few good sensible individuals can change things for the better,for what they do is to make other think and ponder of what is right and what can be reformed and what should be discarded. When that happens, evolution progresses and a glorious future can be achieved. More power to you!

          • Rajeev Gogte
            March 25, 2017 at 1:49 AM


        • vikas
          March 24, 2017 at 2:00 PM

          chun chun kr saare miya sab ko nikalege india se bahar. aur pakistan afghanistan aur bangladesh pr chadhaai hogi. bs intezaar kro aage aage hota hai kya

        • Proud2BPagan
          April 17, 2017 at 3:34 PM


          I truly respect your works,bravery and choices. You are an inspiration for not just muslims,but also to every human being in this war torn world hell bent on establishing religious supremacy through hook or by crook.

          You have inspired me to explore the history of India with a new perspective. If there was a Nobel prize for bravery,you had deserve it.

          Just one small disagreement.

          Please dont accuse all muslims of being responsible for creating pakistan,when they wernt even born back then.

        • Anjan
          April 25, 2017 at 2:25 AM

          Yes sir you are right. Ekkam sattaham bipraha bohudha bhabanti. People can achieve there ultimate goal, by following the different ways. This is the philosophy of Indian culture…..

        • Chand Wattal
          April 26, 2017 at 1:50 AM

          I am a great admirer of yours, Mr Tarek Fateh. Your calls to this nation that has forgotten its past, thanks to our earst while incorrectable politicians, are eye openers. Only if anybody is listening.

      • Sheikh imran zafar
        March 26, 2017 at 10:03 AM

        Waah….here speaks the God himself??? Does education taught you this? Which date was it when Islam was started and founded….??? As long as people will live all religions will live,and Islam will be there till the end of this world….

        • Dibakar Bhattacharjee
          April 26, 2017 at 11:12 PM

          No Sir, either Islam will live and the rest will die or Islam will perish and rest will live..
          There cannot be any co-habitation with Islam. It is a religion of hatred and intolerance.

        • Alka Gupta
          May 2, 2017 at 12:16 PM

          Mr. Zafar, Please accept the truth and leave behind lies. Islam is nothing but a bundle of lies using God as its cover to mislead people. Look at what kind of people, culture and civilization created it. Use logic and common sense that God has provided us. Islam is the other name of terrorism since the time of its creation. As long as it will stay terrorism will not see an end! Accept this fact!

    • February 4, 2017 at 12:17 AM

      Well said

    • Amit
      March 24, 2017 at 12:22 PM

      Interesting response…

    • A k patra
      April 25, 2017 at 12:20 PM

      Good one!

    • VM Chopra
      April 26, 2017 at 7:28 AM

      Great observations by a true Indian

  2. Tariq
    January 24, 2017 at 3:12 AM

    I wonder which Monument is visited more by foreign tourist – khajuraho temple or Taj Mahal?

    • Tarek Fatah
      January 24, 2017 at 4:09 AM

      And that is your defence for destroying the Khajuraho Temple? As an Indian Muslim you should be ashamed of yourself. Taking pride in the marauding of India and destruction of its temples is despicable.

      • Aman
        January 24, 2017 at 4:37 AM

        If destroying of Hindu Temples was mission of ” Muslim” invaders then how ancient Temple in still remain in Allahabad Banaras and Ujjain?

        • Manoj
          January 24, 2017 at 9:34 PM

          Because people in Rajput, Marathas fought to defend them and lot of them were rebuilt e.g. somnath 17 times, mathura 4 times, kashi vishwanath 3 times. And the list goes on. Where they had good hold e.g. Delhi,Punjab,Sindh there are no temples from that era left at all.

        • January 25, 2017 at 9:46 PM

          My dear Aman,
          You are absolutely right. Tarek Fatah has been first expelled from Pakistan then from Saudi Arab from Canada and now seeking assylum in India. Our muslim and non muslim brothers must understand he is trying to divide us and create nuisances by complete false refrences of the past and the present. Why dont we live in ‘Today ‘ and plan for tomorrow ! Why dont we work on science rather than history.!
          Had Tarek Fatah done anything for the ‘ Third World People’ . For the poor, for the downtrodden, for education for harassed class of women or men. Why he always talks about the differance between the muslim and non muslim brethren?
          Could he be nominated for Noble Peace Prize or atlest Magasasay. Why r wekeepng this bug in India ? What concrete had he done or could do for India. We have enough genius scholars authors think tanks and well wishers in India. We dont need a borrowed and an expelled one of three countries to think and work for us.

          • MMI
            January 27, 2017 at 8:09 AM

            @feroz kazi – typical Muslim reaction to Tarek. They simply attack him personally but they never discuss their views on the points he raises. Why would Tarek Fatah do anything to ‘Third world people’? He is not a politician. He simply is a journalist and intellectual raising his views on some issues. ‘Why dont we work on science rather than history’ – can you campaign this in suadi arabia, Iran, Iraq, Yemen etc? It is Islam that demands to you stay in the past with the ideas of jihad, kalphite etc. You are trying to bypass the issue rather than comforting them. If not Tarek, some one else will raise these issues later, It is better to address them.

          • fb
            January 27, 2017 at 8:03 PM

            since when were muslims like you united to begin with?

          • Indian Voter
            January 28, 2017 at 4:37 AM

            Tarak Fateh is speaking the truth. Truth is bitter. It’s high time muslims acknowledge their roots & stop worshipping the maurading, gang rapists, looters & plunderers turks & arabs who came & converted them.

          • satya prasad
            April 25, 2017 at 6:15 AM

            dear brother feroz khazi i agree lets lets live today so can you guys follow indian law , why muslim personal law , now days are changed one country one law no discounts as per religion do you agree citizen of this country should have a uniform civil code you if agree you are true indian

          • Alka Gupta
            May 2, 2017 at 12:33 PM

            Mr. Kazi,
            Tarek Fatah is doing the greatest job of bringing the facts in front of the people. How many people in this world have the nerves to speak the truth and be fearless. It is a fact that muslims are the most regressive minded people on earth. Thanks, to the culture and religion they adhere to. We Indians know this fact very well and still have to deal with them unfortunately! All the mosques in India are built on top of our temples. All mosques in India should be removed and temples must be restored. India is the land of Hinduism not some Arab impure, barbaric and dirty culture and religion. It is in the best interest of these misguided Indian muslims, Pakistani and Bangladeshi muslims to go back to their roots which is Hinduism Vedic culture. Only then will they be able to come out of the darkness of a ugly world of islam and be educated, cultivated and prosperous like other Hindus in India. But if these muslims don’t want to change then they will live in this darkness of hell forever and that’s a fact of life.
            As far as helping these poor muslims is concerned why don’t these muslims help each other if they are so in love of their own people or ask for help from these rich Saudis whose religion they adhere to as more precious than their own country India or their own life.
            The truth is that the whole world is seeing the ugly face of Islam which India has seen through its past. It’s up to now these muslims to choose between leaving a dirty barbaric culture and religion and go back to the culture and religion of their ancestors which is Hindu Vedic culture but, who were forced to convert to Islam.

        • Anjan
          April 25, 2017 at 2:32 AM

          Aman thanks for your positive argument. Arabian inveder they demolished lots of temple. Still they are trying to roots out, there mission haven’t over yet…….

      • Tariq
        January 24, 2017 at 5:06 AM

        No.. I am not supporting the destruction of temples at all.

        Are you saying that Muslim Invaders just looted India?

        You should be ashamed to be say that the Destruction of a Historical Mosque like Babri Masjid is justified. So a Mob breaking a mosque to okay but the destruction of Bamiyan Buddha is wrong. Do not be a hypocrite.. Breaking of any historical monument by anyone is wrong regardless of the era. If there is a claim of Ram temple..then we have a judiciary and a court…not a mob law.

        • Abhijeet
          January 24, 2017 at 7:22 AM

          Do you want the list of destroyed temple by Muslim invaders.. And what you got to cry for always Babri masjid,which was build by destroying ayodha temple.. Cheap excuse..

          • Ami Jain
            January 24, 2017 at 10:43 PM

            Very well said!

        • Vivek
          January 24, 2017 at 7:26 AM

          Bamiyan was not built after destroying a mosque
          Babri masjid was built after destroying a hindu temple

          Babar didnt approach any judiciary.. He followed the mob law.. So you have got the reply in the same language from hindus

          • Indian Voter
            January 28, 2017 at 9:46 AM

            Babar didnot follow any mob law. He followed the cult that preaches to hate kafirs / infidels, you & me. That is what destroyers of Bamiyan did.

        • Prateek
          January 24, 2017 at 7:33 AM

          Sir, the Babri masjid was made upon the destroyed Ram temple which was much much older, not that either is justified but you can compare destruction of one mosque in an isolated event to hundreds of incidents of loot and rape and destruction throughout the last millennia. If that isn’t good enough, read about the 7 genocides of Kashmiri Hindus by a community that may not be named in the last 600 years

        • Pandey
          January 24, 2017 at 7:50 AM

          In your self righteousness dont designate it as ‘Babri Mosque’.Hindus call it a temple destroyed by Muslim rulers forcefully and built a mosque on the site.Thus Hindus took revenge of injustice and demolished it.

          Like muslims in their favourable time did not ask any court to demolish the temple,how can you expect Hindus wait for a court orders?

          Can you deny hundreds of temples demolition in various parts of hindustan by muslim invaders?

        • MMI
          January 24, 2017 at 7:54 AM

          Tariq – If you are not supporting demolition of temples, how can you support the existence of Babri masjid which was built after demolishing most beloved temple of Hindus. There is no evidence of a temple built on demolished site of another religious structure. And if any exists, all Hindus will come forward to demolish such temple which does not happen in case of Muslims. Unfortunately not a single Indian Muslim came forwarded supporting reconstruction of Ram Mandir knowing well that the Masjid was built on after demolishing the temple. Have some honesty as you live in civilized societies.

          • shreyashbhau
            January 26, 2017 at 4:43 AM

            first at all there is no space for worshipping god or temple in islam….then why instead of making fuss our Muslim brothers doesn’t compromise for one single masjid??

          • Tariq
            January 30, 2017 at 7:56 AM

            Support the existence of Babri Masjid..the mosque was there till 1989.. What Babur did was in 16th century…. what hinduvta did was in 20th century..there is a difference. If you can Mob rule exists..then dont cry to what muslim invaders did. Simple as that

          • MMI
            January 30, 2017 at 9:07 AM

            @Tariq – What Babur did in 16 the century was hate, aggression and humiliation. What people did 1989 is reaction to that aggression after failing to get a single Muslim at least condemn the existence of mosque built on a temple demolition. Indian Muslims continue to admire a Turkish invaders who destroyed local culture just because of their religion.
            You are arguing for respect for law. Muslims talk about law and order only in places where they are in minority. Comparing (in terms of respect for law) Indian Hindus to Indian Muslims is not fair comparison. You should compare India (where Hindus are in majority) vs Pakistan (where Muslims like Indian muslims are in majority). In Pakistan, temples are demolished (in your 21st century) almost on daily basis. When Pakistan was created, there were 20% Hindus and today it is 1.6%. Javed Akthar rightly says that Pakistan serves as lab for Hindutva in India. If a Indian hindu want to imagine how it will be when muslims are in majoirty in India, they just have to look at Pakistan.

          • MMI
            January 30, 2017 at 9:45 AM

            @Tariq – also you missed my point of argument. If there is any temple built on the destruction of a mosque, muslims will not be forced to go the extreme position of mob law. Majority Hindus would come forward, demolish such temple and make it easy for muslim brothers (just the way majority hindus cam forward after dadri incident and stopped it happening further).

          • MojoRisin
            February 5, 2017 at 5:27 AM

            What Babur and the other invaders did was criminal from a moral/religious standpoint. The mob that destroyed the mosque sought to reinstate a temple based on their belief that lord Ram was born there. I.e. That place has tremendous significance for Hindus.
            An equivalent modern situation would be if Trump were to demolish the Mecca, and build a church in its place!

        • rajesh choudhary
          January 24, 2017 at 8:11 AM

          Not only Ram Mandir, there are many temple, and university like Nalanda destroyed by muslim invader….is our court is able to give justice for all the destruction. every where muslims try to destroy the existing of other religion.

        • Kanu Singh
          January 24, 2017 at 8:27 AM

          It seems that the decision of a court which is based on scientific, documentary and archeological evidence is of no value to you. You are unwilling to accommodate your neighbors at all. This my way or highway mentality led to partition of 1947, is the reason for World-vs-Islam situation and will finally lead to demise of such inflexible ideology.

        • MMI
          January 24, 2017 at 8:55 AM

          ‘Let judiciary decide’ – this is being used by many often. Akbarruddin owaisi said ‘let police be taken away for 15 minutes, muslims will show to Hindus…’. Whenever senior owaisi was asked by media about it, his reply always been (he thinks himself smart) ‘let judiciary decide’. But no muslim said ‘let judiciary decide’ when Salman Rushdie published a book. They build pressure on government to ban it immediately, No muslim says court will decide about Taslima. They beat her up. None like you came forward to say let the law decide instead of beating her. When painful to you, you don’t have to wait for the law. But others do.

          • Sanjay Rawat
            January 24, 2017 at 7:51 PM

            They don’t listen to law too. “Court will decide” is their just one of the escapade till their “time” comes.

        • Pankaj
          January 24, 2017 at 10:08 AM

          I think u r a madarsa educated guy… First u demolish temples, etc. And built mosques on it… Then hindus demolish ur mosques and u blame hindus for it… Whr wr ur forefathers wen temples wr demolished by ur Muslims bro… U creeps r useless jst increasing population.

        • CKM
          January 24, 2017 at 1:17 PM

          What about the time when Babur destroyed the Ram Mandir there and built Mosque. It’s not only about Hindu and Muslim, its about reclaiming something which belonged to Hindus but were snatched. Hindus never invaded any other countries because they believe in peace and prosperity. Had that mosque been built on a separate land even next to the temple, I would have been against the demolition. It’s all about reclaiming and nothing else. Regarding Taj Mahal, there are many truths which are still buried and many Indian government doesn’t want to come out so as to maintain harmony between two communities; so let’s better not talk about it. Taj Mahal is equally loved by Hindus and Muslims in India and abroad; so there is no need to politicize it

        • Manoj
          January 24, 2017 at 9:36 PM

          There is nothing historic about Babri except shame.

        • Indian Voter
          January 28, 2017 at 4:41 AM

          Intelligent (if they exist) muslims in India should ensure that not only Ram Janmabhoomi is given back to Hindus but also Kashi Vishwanath & Mathura Temple too where masjids have been build by maurading arabs.

          Problem is muslims in India like all over the world are in shackles made by hate spewing mullahs & moulvis & are all cursed to live in the 7th century.

        • Alka Gupta
          May 2, 2017 at 12:44 PM

          Mr. Tariq,
          Shame on you and your intelligence. What kind of people are you muslims. Are you all mentally challenged that you cannot see the truth! The truth is that all the mosques in India were built by breaking our temples! What are these mosques after all. A place, a room where muslims gather to pray to their Allah! of which they have no knowledge of, pass sermons, discuss politics against people of other faiths and pass hate speech. Their own muslim women can’t enter the mosques from the front door but. only from the back door and stay in dark. They are suppose to eat only after the men have eaten and are seggregated in separate rooms like cattles. These people are still so backward and follows the barbaric and wrong culture of Arabs.

          India. Pakistan, Bangladesh is the land of Hindus and all people born in India are Hindus by birth!
          We need to get rid of these dirty and unholy mosques all together!

      • Sanjay Rawat
        January 24, 2017 at 7:48 PM

        People like Tariq will always be in a denial mode. Acceptance will kill his identity.

      • Ami Jain
        January 24, 2017 at 10:41 PM

        Very well said Tarekji! ? The writer had courage to speak tge truth! Vande mataram!

      • Manish Sanghavi
        January 25, 2017 at 12:42 AM

        I feel children are more sensible and tolerant when it comes to religion. They befriend other children of different religions and are more accommodating and open. But the educated / uneducated adults are more rigid as far as religions are concerned.

        A good religion promotes friendship, peace and understanding between people. The very purpose of a religion is to prevent conflicts and Not create them.

        It must Promote good practices, art, culture and education, moral values, fair practices, ensure practice of law and order and create an Orderly Society. A religion must be open to New ideas, should be a healthy debate in the benefit of the society

        Every religion is different from place to place and preachings will differ based on the good and bad practices followed in that era in that very place.

        Draws a line and demarcates between the good and the bad through preaching by the scholars.

        A religion has to change with time to suit the good and bad practices being followed and continue with the demarcation.

        A religion which does not update itself should be scrapped as obsolete and unfit for the present time.

      • R Pradhan
        April 6, 2017 at 3:56 AM

        I am Nepalese Hindu.
        We also witnessed a mass destruction of our fine masterpiece of temples for the crime we never committed against the Arabs and Central Asian Muslims/Mugals. The Sultan of Bengal invaded Nepal (Kathmandu Valley) some 800 years before destroying almost all Temples Vihars, statues sparing (except) a “Baraha” temple which had a “Swine/pig” head believed by Hindus an incarnation of “Vishnu”.

        I don’t ask our sub continent muslim to revert into Hinduism rather ask them at least to acknowledge (say yes) the crime committed against our/your civilization by forcing our/your ancestors to convert into their belief.

        R. Pradhan

        • Sharma
          April 25, 2017 at 3:41 AM

          Pradhan…True,brother..We r hindus of Bharat Varsh before India,Nepal nd Porkistan,Afghania,Bangladesh became Countries in modern sense ….The coward ancestors of these ignorant fools converted fearing death/persecution…. Subcontinent is ruled by only one law-Sanatan Dharma….We might be different nations but as long as we breath Hinduism,we r children nd Heirs of d Oldest Civilisation on d planet which predates life…..Dharmo Rakshati Rakshitaha!!!Bharat Mata ki Jai!!!

    • Chandra Mohan Singh Bisht
      January 24, 2017 at 4:39 AM

      Hmm, after choping hands of those workers who helped in making of Taj , aint you proud of this history ? well many historians strongly believes that TM was build after destroying lord Shiva temple “Tejo Mahal”

    • ashwani
      January 24, 2017 at 6:39 AM

      Mr. Tariq,

      As per one disruptive theory by Prof PN Oak, even Tajmahal was built over an ancient rajput palace by Shah jahan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P._N._Oak
      Please read his work. Also as Mr. Fateh mentioned, thats not justified. India has lost immense knowledge and heritage by Muslim invaders by consistent attacks of 1000 years.

      • Tariq
        January 30, 2017 at 7:59 AM

        And gained a lot of heritage from the Muslims. Dont forget you need a Red Fort to hoist our flag. So appreciate what we have also got..And yes the language we are typing is in English who robbed us for 200 years. I am not crying on that..maybe you shouldnt also

        • A
          March 18, 2017 at 4:54 PM

          The Red Fort is not Islamic, Its Hindu. Deal with It. You’ll gave us nothing, you’ll took everything for 1100 years and are stil creating a genocide in Kashmir. Hindutva did not invade any country or rape your mothers. It exists because your sadistic Arab filth invaded other lands and destruoyed their cultures. it did not the reason today why your Arab and Turkish heros raped our country for 1100 years. Yes , get used to it, neither the Taj, neither the Red Fort, neither the Jama Masjid, neither the immambaras in Uttar Pradesh are islamic, they are Rajput palaces stolen by filthy Invadors. Your Rahul Gandhi cannot protect Your lies anymore from the truth.

        • May 2, 2017 at 1:08 PM

          Mr. Tariq do you know who built Red Fort of Delhi. It was built by King Anangpal in1060 AD.
          Also, forts and palaces of Agra were all originally built by Rajput kings before they were looted by barbaric muslims.

          By suggesting and supporting muslim invaders these mislims have proved that they are traitors and supporters of terrorist acts.



      January 24, 2017 at 6:48 AM

      had it been intact, I am sure more people would have visited Khujaraho temple.

    • abhya
      January 24, 2017 at 10:11 AM

      Khajuraho is the beauty of Human civilization and as an Hindu i am proud of that. It need well educated mind to understand that, which is something beyond the reach of sex-mongers. How many Taj Mahals Muslim invaders built in their native place …….? They just destroyed some parts of the temples and converted that in the form of Tomb, Babri Dhancha, Gayanwayapi Masjid are few examples of this satanic act.

    • Asif
      January 24, 2017 at 2:51 PM

      “What India Did to Muslims”

      Dear Mr. Tariq,

      So, the ultimate arbiters, you make, are the “foreign tourist” count. How about the head count at the Disneyland vs. J. Paul Getty Museum both situated in Southern California: What would that prove? Art appreciation or the ketch appreciation? Visiting Florence and Venice as oppose to Beijing and Hong Kong? Well Sir., tastes and preferences do vary; we all bring to bear upon our individual choices our own cultivation of tastes tinged by education and broadly speaking our readings education.

      Mr, Tariq, your singular and a one-liner of a question won’t do; instead you have to better elucidate as to what exactly was your intention behind. Was it merely a desire on your part to sound profound to us visitors to this web-sight? Or, you knowing the acctual tally count and therefore desiring to spring on us the desparity that there might exists between those sights at issue. However, your musing is in poor taste, especially after reading such an heart wrenching account above of our Hindu civilization by the hands of the interlopers from the muslim North and West Asia, and the consequences of their aftermath that we are still reeling from. Have a care Sir,, Mr. Fatah is engaged in reviving a dead mass of human tissue that is what the converted people of the Sub-Continent has come to represent. Join in in the effort, do enlighten, offer a shoulder toward helping the wheel move up from and out of the stagnant pool of muslim ignorance and miasma.

      Or are you just contend with the business as usual which has been the norm for well over a millennium in our case? Yes, the Taj Mahal is absolutely gorgeous and an unrivaled engineering marvel; an object of wonderment a testament of one man’s love for his wife, etc.; but does that take away any of the sublimity, the beauty, the grandeur, the intricate Hindu philosophy, and the Hindu mythology woven into its voluptuous female dancing figures, columns, domes and in general art and architecture? Give it up Sir., these cheap (what we call in urdu. Chichowray) questions in an effort to cop some cockamamie profundity,

      I recommend you Nirad Chaudhuri’s book, “The Island of Circe.” Here you’ll learn why India can’t be escaped from; She absorbs any and all, whosoever dares come into her folds. She the black hole of a civilization from which you may never escape. India in return has left you reeling in such a quotidian confusion, really an identity crisis that you don’t even have any recollection nor knowledge, you know not who you really are; a few generations separate you from a poor Hindu peasant farmer. Blissful ignorance!

      Good luck and God bless.



      • May 2, 2017 at 1:16 PM

        Mr. Asif,
        You have proved yourself that you are a traitor, and an imbecile!

    • RAJ
      January 24, 2017 at 8:46 PM

      Chutiye taj mahal ek hindu shiv temple tha

    • Manoj
      January 24, 2017 at 9:26 PM

      Taj mahal is also build on a Hindu temple. The same way as gurudwaras and temples in Kashmir and Pakistan now converted to mosques and mausoleus.

    • vivek
      January 24, 2017 at 10:42 PM

      When you go tp Real History of Taj Mahal. You will find it Hindu fort/temple. But It got converted.
      Please enlighten yourself.

    • Vml
      January 25, 2017 at 7:39 AM

      By the way Taj Mahal is covered hindu temple as well … Sharpen your knowledge buddy

      • Vml
        January 25, 2017 at 7:39 AM

        **converted …..

    • Vivek
      April 25, 2017 at 1:30 AM

      Khajuraho speaks a lot about are ancestor ,it show how liberal they were ,they did not use to make their women hide behind veil without their consent . N if u read the article u vll realize many of the Hindu monument has been destroyed ,so 1 can say that we are only seeing fraction of monument.

  3. Subba
    January 24, 2017 at 5:30 AM

    I just came across this article , very thankful to tarek fatah for showing the true history.

    I still do not understand how any religion can help human’s progress,

    why cant we accept we are all just human creatures and die one day,as simple as that

    we never owned anything and never will.

    I think Hinduism as a way to lead a value full life and not a religion of some sort.


  4. Sundeep Parija
    January 24, 2017 at 5:57 AM

    it is good to remember history but I feel Hindus should not antagonise the Muslims in India. Instead Muslims should feel safe, confident and part of a resurgent and inclusive India. Muslims should feel happy and at peace in a secular India. That would be a good and true Hindu reply to the thousand years of Muslim sectarianism. A peaceful and inclusive answer to a thousand years of violence and suppression.

    • Jitendra
      April 25, 2017 at 4:30 PM

      @Sundeep Parija,
      “That would be a good and true Hindu reply to the thousand years of Muslim sectarianism.”
      Are we really looking only for a good reply?

      Shouldn’t we be aware of Islam’s tendency to not give a damn what we think? Shouldn’t we realise they don’t care and keep on pushing their agenda throughout the world? Can we just close our eyes and think everything is perfect? If yes, till when can we pretend everything to be fine? Till Muslims become majority in India? It is set to happen due to population growth among Muslims. After that what will happen? Will future world not laugh at our stupidity? Of not trying to understand real intentions despite of hints we get from all history and current Muslim activities throughout world?

      We should learn from history! We should trying to show our existence! We should convey that we don’t appreciate our kindness/humility being mistaken for our weakness! And we should try our best to change them while we can, to make them be more adjusting to civilized world, be more democratic. Make them feel that if they don’t become secular then they can’t enjoy rights that comes along with it as well. Most of all show them the mirror, show jahiliyya in them, with which we are still forced to fight in 21st century.

  5. January 24, 2017 at 8:41 AM

    As u said abt temple. Temples are made after rituals. As per our religion, God stays in temple once the complete ritual is carried. We worship god in all form including status. So distroy temple is like act against God. As per my knowledge Jamia masjid was built on temple. Court give slow justice to rape victims, kashmiri pandits. They r very slow and do not wish to act on any verdicts against religion view point or logical. Will u accept if the verdicts support temple must be built. As per my knowledge u can destroy masjid as they r place to worship and u can built grand masjid in other place. Muslim do not believe in God in statue or in object. Correct me on it. If I am wrong.

  6. January 24, 2017 at 8:47 AM

    Tarek, thank u from bottom of my heart. U have opened my eyes on most of Indian Muslim thinking. I loved ur show fateh ka fatwa. They r mislead by mullah and prominent leader. Made them scrap goat for vote bank politics. They r Pakistani by heart. Misuse religion and people for their greed. They do not talk or act for development of people or country.
    Thanks once again to tarek.

  7. Wisdom Indian
    January 24, 2017 at 10:02 AM

    Tariq please do not justify with Babari Masjid and too built on destroying a temple by Babur. Lacs of Hindu Temples destroyed by islamic fanatics and those are remarkably great architectures and knowledge ! Do not compare your knowledge and wisdom with Sir Tarek Fatah….

  8. Divek
    January 24, 2017 at 10:38 AM

    totally agree with you sir

  9. shailendra
    January 24, 2017 at 10:47 AM

    Truth is not in books … truth is in your heart and mind… if you read a sentence after well study one can easily judge what is the truth… but matter is that whether that individual accepts his/her own voice from heart and mind or just ignore it under some influences or for the support of some hidden agenda…

  10. CKM
    January 24, 2017 at 1:23 PM

    Tarek Sahib, I am a huge fan of yours. I really liked your concept of “Allah ka Islam v/s Mullah ka Islam.” It is not the case of only Muslims, but all other religions also (like Hindus). Coming to your article, I fully support your views on it. India was the first in the world to have a University (Nalanda University, if I am correct). Hindus are peace loving people (those who believe in Bhagwan ka Hindu, not Ponga-pandit ka Hindu), they never attacked any country. This has somehow worked to our disadvantage as we were attacked several times, by Muslim invaders, Britishers etc. this has led us to a mixed culture; and it is a very big challenge for Indian govt to maintain the harmony among them. Luckily, maximum of Indian (be it Hindu, Muslim or any other religion) are smart and intelligent; however, we all should understand our roots and should accept some basic facts.

    Hats off to you sir

  11. Kalpesh Chhaya
    January 24, 2017 at 1:36 PM

    How can Babe Masjid be justified where it was a temple in the ancient time… It is evident and a proven fact… That there was a temple and it was destroyed…

    Secondly Babe Masjid was not at all functioning and any masjid can be shifted as it is done in Arab countries very easily if that comes in the path of development….

    Lastly the place where idols are not inplaced that place morally and religiously can be shifted….

    So this is not at all an issue of debate…. Jay Shree Ram

  12. Kamal
    January 24, 2017 at 8:12 PM

    To me Tarek is a true Bharat Ratna.if modi is a true nationalist.he should give Bharat Ratna to Mr. Tarek.

  13. Neeraj Bhatt
    January 25, 2017 at 3:50 AM

    Nice share. First and foremost the destruction of Babri masjid is not at all an attack on a particular religion or its god. In fact a mosque is not a religious place. Its just a community property. Loads of Muslims pray on the road, are they are going to sue the municipality for excavating that road for a sever project?
    A mosque can be easily relocated unlike a Hindu temple which has deep historical roots. And mind you mosques do get demolished in Saudia as well.

  14. Manish Sanghavi
    January 25, 2017 at 8:46 AM

    A good religion should have a script made by intellectuals which promotes

    1 High Ideals,

    2 preach high moral and ethical values,

    3 should be open minded, be open to healthy debates, should Not be accepted blindly at face value,

    4 should be adaptable to changes,

    5 should suit current scenario of the world,

    6 should Not be forced upon people to accept it as a Religion forcefully, rather people should feel respected to follow it and be a member or a follower of the religion.

    7 Should treat all humans equal, should respect gender equality,

    8 Should Not create conflicts,

    9 Should promote universal brother hood & peace,

    10 Should promote education, art, culture,

    11 Should promote coexistence with Nature and surroundings,

    12 Should Not exploit the weak,

    13 Should provide justice and should be able to justify itself.

    14 A good religion draws a line and clearly demarcates between the good & the bad practices being followed.

    15 Every land and every era will have its own good and bad practices. The religion draws a line what to follow and what Not to follow.

    16 A good religion preaches and promotes Tolerance, Non violence,

    17 Promotes a Win win solution for all.

    18 A good religion changes with time to suit,

    19 A good religion should be easy to understand for even the uneducated masses till the lowest level

    20 Should Not promote violence, destruction of other religions or undermine any other religion.

    21 Should prove itself by it’s very virtues as the most superior religion

    22 A good religion looks down upon illicit relations, trades and customs and strongly condemns it.

    Kindly carry out an introspection of all the religions presently being followed the world over.

    God bless all.

    January 25, 2017 at 8:58 AM

    Even if the Islamic invaders had destroyed temples, chaityas (Buddhist temples), etc. and built their mosques on those, it does not make any sense now to again destroy those mosques, etc. to build temples, etc. That way every invader, even Hindu invaders, did destroy the enemy’s temples and looted those. During invasions all sorts of destruction, plunder and killings happened and do happen even now. But a civilized society should not tolerate such acts nor encourage those. First a full stop should be put to indiscriminate building of temples, mosques, churches, etc. which hides the real monetary and political cum social greed spurring those efforts and not any spiritual or ethical high morals. Religion should be strictly separated from state and political spheres and as far as possible consigned to individual choice and private efforts, to be strictly regulated by the society through state/relevant institutions. Religious conversions should be banned except in case of purely voluntary individual conversions through attested affidavits approved by judicial magistrates. There should be no coercion on spouses to likewise convert or any application of such conversion to children even if both parents convert. The children, if needed, be taken out of such parents’ clutches, kept in state homes/social centres and brought up in a secular atmosphere in the culture to which they belonged at birth and should be left to decide on any conversion only after they attain maturity. Population explosions and illegal immigrations of certain religious minorities which threatens the demographic pattern and hence the very survival of our country should be prevented by various disincentives and harsh treatment of illegal migrants and compulsory deportation of them in majority of cases. At any rate they should not be enfranchised, and if already enfranchised, now disenfranchised. The excessive privileges enjoyed by the minorities and so-called downtrodden castes should be abolished and as far as possible any reservations have to be on economic and really social backwardness based ones which do not promote casteism and religious fundamentalism. Vote bank politics are ruining the country and if monotheistic Judaic religious cults secure majorities by all the current detestable means and other ways, then we will have no redemption; our country will surely go to the dogs.

      March 30, 2017 at 12:19 AM


    January 25, 2017 at 10:20 AM

    I remember having read this article when it was published, and had been thinking about it off and on. Since last about one year, I had been frantically searching this article, and thanks to Tarek Fatah, I have found it. Yet another proof of the Law of Attraction elucidated by Rhonda Byrne in her ‘The Secret’. I wonder why cann’t I look for money with same zeal!
    About the article, what can one say? Coming from someone in Pakistan, it is a surprise.
    If only the Muslims had heart to apologize for what they have done with us over last 1000 years————————————-

  17. Raaj
    January 25, 2017 at 11:55 AM

    Tarek Sir. Did you see this Mulla on youtube. He openly challenged you. Take a look at it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUYqMomsMYY

  18. Darshan Dave
    January 26, 2017 at 10:42 AM

    Now we can understand why American people like Robert Spencer and Donald Trump.

  19. Amit
    February 2, 2017 at 5:57 PM

    Thanks for writing truth…. i am appreciating your courage… !!!!!

  20. Pankaj Singh
    February 13, 2017 at 7:48 AM

    Hat’s off to u sir…….there r not many peoples who accepted the TRUTH and making others aware of it……..u r my hero sir………..hopefully others will also follow the path of TRUTH, LOVE and PEACE…….

  21. Aamir Syed
    March 24, 2017 at 12:38 PM

    Whoever wrote this piece (definitely not a historian) does not even know that India was not invaded by the Arabs or West Asians in the 11th century. The invaders were mostly Turks from Central Asia and Afghans from ‘Greater’ India. Idiots …

    • Tarek Fatah
      March 24, 2017 at 1:17 PM

      Really Aamir Syed? Muhammad Bin Qasim was a Turk? And where in the world did you end up with the name ‘Syed’, Uzbekistan?

      • satish seth
        March 25, 2017 at 7:23 AM

        Ha Ha Ha. Nailed him. Bhaaji tussi great o. Hats Off 🙂

  22. i am M
    March 24, 2017 at 5:23 PM

    First thing ..Saving Babri is not our job (Muslim’s) … Allah is there to protect His place …these Babri thing is now not a issue on religious ground now it have become a political issue..so it’s batter to give this place to build mandir …. or waise bhi Musjid ek paak jagah hai …or hum to Muslim’s hai jinhone zero invent kiya …hum wo log hai jin K wajah se ye science ne itni tarraki Kari … khud ki reputation ki parwah to hai nahi kam se kam RasulAllah SAW. Ki izzat rakho ….

  23. Rameez Ahmed Siddique
    March 25, 2017 at 1:43 PM

    Dear Tarek,

    Your history seems a little weak here but even if for sake of argument we agree that muslim invaders demolished a lot of temples, what is your intention here for addressing things which happened centuries ago.

    Do you want our Hindu brothers to be our enemy today for what our ancestors did centuries ago?

    If my Hindu Brother wants to live peacefully with us, what is your problem?

    Why being a hate monger Mr Tarek Fatah?

    Why do you want to spread Hate?

    You are talking about demolition? why don’t you talk about things built by muslims? Who built the Taj Mahal, A hindu?

    Mr Tarek Fatah, just Incase if you happen to be a muslim, Allah Said in Qur’an, Do not follow blindly any information of which you have no direct knowledge. (Using your faculties of perception and conception) you must verify it for yourself. In the Court of your Lord, you will be held accountable for your hearing, sight, and the faculty of reasoning [17/36].

    So might need to get your Data right.

    May Allah give you Hidayah

    • Tarek Fatah
      March 25, 2017 at 8:05 PM


      My intention is to show you the mirror and save you from the day your arrogance of flaunting your ‘Siddique’ name as being a descendent of Arab invaders of Hindustan bears fruit. If you do not like what you see in this mirror, that is not the fault of the mirror or me.

      Your disgusting attitude that shows no remorse at what your forefathers did in raping Bharat tells me how deep is the rot among India’s Muslims, specially the Urdu-speaking lot.

      Go repent.

      • Raghu
        April 3, 2017 at 12:09 AM

        Sir, all misbelief are soo deep rooted now that, if you show mirror to them they will break the mirror instead of changing their attitude.
        This applies to all religion…..
        God bless you sir, I pray for your long & health life 🙂

      March 30, 2017 at 12:25 AM


  24. Abhik
    March 25, 2017 at 4:17 PM


  25. March 29, 2017 at 11:21 AM

    Dear Tarek Fateh,
    I have been reading & watching few of your videos and was wondering are there any other south Asians muslims who very passionately show their voice with straight talking. In India we are very used to sugar coated views.
    Now a query:( ignore if few facts are wrong- I am not an expert)
    Muslim majority in Thailand is in armed conflict against Buddhist majority, same against majority Christian Phillipines, same in China, Chechnya ( indian subcontinent we all know).
    Another fact : Malaysia with 60% muslims – minorities are better off, indonesia has Hindu majority Bali , muslim eqypt has substantial Christian population.
    I did analyse the population distribution of countries with Christian & muslims: they don’t show much difference is distribution ( like %of countries with 95% majority etc).
    So the query:
    1) is this muslim extremism a problem of last 50+ yrs ?
    2) if so is there any organised movement with in muslim society that is fighting it?

    To OTHER MUSLIM PARTICIPANTS LIKE SYED , SIDDIQUE: pl keep sharing your views , it adds a perspective -as long as it healthy 🙂

  26. VP
    April 1, 2017 at 3:25 PM

    Dear Tarek Sir,

    I am watching all the episodes of Fatah Ka Fatwa. I understand ome point that there are rigid rules ( I am refering to sharia) that are taught to Indian muslims saying that they taught by Islam and which actually is not the case. Some of our brothers are yet to come to terms with that but the way more and more people are joining you it will not take much time for people to accept that. As I can see the responses or comments to your posts
    more and more people seeking the truth. As a spectator I know one, you doing great service to our nation, our muslim brother by making us to interospect. I always like one thing which you say and follow “Speak only truth at all costs”. These debates of yours make us interospect our religions too.I try to follow the same and hope I will have enough courage like you to face the consequences. Our muslim brother dont have worry aboutany repercussions ffrom hindus in India if they just accept that yes there were atrocities done by muslim rulers. That is fact, and accepting a fact develops understanding and bring all of us closer.

    Hope soon in the future we will get rid off the hindu brother and muslim brother and will just use brother. I am not afan of those words but had to use to put my 2 paise.

  27. R Pradhan
    April 6, 2017 at 4:09 AM

    I am Nepalese Hindu.
    We also witnessed a mass destruction of our fine masterpiece of temples for the crime we never committed against the Arabs and Central Asian Muslims/Mugals.

    The Sultan of Bengal invaded Nepal (Kathmandu Valley) some 800 years before destroying almost all Temples Vihars, statues sparing (except) a “Baraha” temple which had a “Swine/pig” head believed by Hindus an incarnation of “Vishnu”.

    I don’t ask our sub continent muslim to revert into Hinduism rather ask them at least to acknowledge (say yes) the crime committed against our/your civilization by forcing our/your ancestors to convert into their belief.

    R. Pradhan

  28. Sundeep Jain
    April 25, 2017 at 8:22 AM

    Mr. Siddique,

    your quote “If my Hindu Brother wants to live peacefully with us, what is your problem?”
    you still do not get it – Its not what your Hindu Brother wants, its what you want, Hindus knows there are multiple paths to god, one of these is Islam. Do you agree ??


  29. Abcd
    April 28, 2017 at 5:30 PM

    I used to dislike (not hate) a typical religion. From the day I watched Fatah ka fatwa I became more sensible to that religion.

    Speak the truh even if it cause harm to you. I like this part most. Some interest grew within to study it. Lots of controversial issues are discussed in the sho. Why do not Fatah sir invite Javed Akhtar, a.r. Rahman like personalities in his show? May be one day you will invite Malala Yusufjai from Pakistan. Discussion should be among gentlemen and women with EDUCATION, nnot among some blind rule followers. Sati, widow marriage once practiced in India. How was those practices got abolished?

    I have heard lots about Balochistan . Why do not you write a book on the same topic? Give authentic proof like picture etc in that book so that world may know what happens there. You may write in hindi too. As long as people read and learn they will discuss things.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *